If you’ve been bitten by the SNAFU that is RegisterFly, there is a new community site that tries to provide help and some answers. At the very least, you can go there and join the pity party.
And by the way, DO NOT, under any circumstances, submit payment to RegisterFly. As I understand it, they are now a rogue operation, accepting payment, but not actually registering/renewing your domains. I urge you to transfer your domains to a new registrar ASAP. GoDaddy is offering a refugee program:
https://www.godaddy.com/gdshop/transfers/registerfly.asp
Maybe ICANN will swoop in on their white horse and save the day, but I wouldn’t count on it.